Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!

Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!

Share this post

Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!
Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!
3.) Emotional Maturity Isn’t a Trait — It’s a Skill (Especially in Conflict)

3.) Emotional Maturity Isn’t a Trait — It’s a Skill (Especially in Conflict)

If love is easy, you're not growing. If conflict is ugly, you're not practicing. Here’s how to build emotional maturity where it matters most — in the middle of the mess.

Matthew Maynard, LMFT's avatar
Matthew Maynard, LMFT
May 27, 2025
∙ Paid
2

Share this post

Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!
Honey, We Screwed Up The Family!
3.) Emotional Maturity Isn’t a Trait — It’s a Skill (Especially in Conflict)
Share

Let’s start with the truth no one wants to hear:

Most people are emotionally immature in conflict.

Not because they’re narcissists. Not because they’re broken. Not even because they’re bad people.

Because emotional maturity — especially in conflict — wasn’t modeled, taught, or reinforced in the homes they grew up in.

So they learned how to perform emotional closeness, but not how to regulate through emotional chaos.


What Emotional Immaturity in Conflict Actually Looks Like

  • Yelling to get heard.

  • Stonewalling to protect yourself.

  • Making it about being right, not being connected.

  • Saying you’re “fine” when you’re visibly seething.

  • Reacting with sarcasm, shutdown, or passive-aggression.

You might even sound like your parents — even though you swore you never would.

And here’s the kicker: even people who are emotionally intelligent can be emotionally immature in conflict.

Because knowing the language of emotions and living it out when you feel threatened are two very different skills.


You Don’t Need More Empathy. You Need More Practice.

Everyone wants to “feel seen.” But not everyone can stay grounded long enough to actually see.

That’s what emotional maturity is:

The ability to stay in connection even when everything inside you wants to disconnect, defend, or destroy.

And you don’t get that from a podcast, or a book, or a weekend seminar.

You get it by practicing it — like a muscle — over and over again.

You’ll suck at first. You’ll fumble. You’ll over-explain or under-respond. You’ll feel like a hypocrite.

Good. That’s what growth looks like.


The Pinball Machine Effect: Why Conflict Feels Like Chaos

Here’s why most conflict conversations fall apart:

In real-time, you’re activating multiple parts of your brain at once, and it creates a flurry of internal chaos.

You’re trying to:

• Figure out how you actually feel
• Find the right words to express it
• Track how your partner is reacting
• Respond to their response
• Clarify your original point while managing your emotions

Meanwhile, your partner might interrupt, correct, or misinterpret something you said — and suddenly you’re defending a word instead of staying in the feeling.

It’s like trying to finish a puzzle while someone keeps flipping the table.

This is why people get lost in conflict.

They’re not just expressing — they’re processing while being misunderstood at the same time.

That’s why conversations feel like a pinball machine — bouncing around, unpredictable, chaotic.

The goal isn’t to win. The goal is to understand and connect before clarifying.

Listen longer. Let the conversation breathe.
Be more curious about what your partner means than about the words they’re using.

This is where radical open emotional curiosity becomes the quiet skill that separates mature conflict from messy chaos.
It buys you time to clarify your own experience and make space for your partner’s.

Because when both people are processing and reacting at the same time, the conversation unravels — not because they don’t care, but because they can’t stay present.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Honey, We Screwed Up The Family! to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Matthew Maynard, LMFT
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share